Ticket #5710 (closed defect: fixed)
[Regression] 3D support: Celestia renders textures incorrectly
| Reported by: | Technologov | Owned by: | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Priority: | major | Component: | 3D support |
| Version: | VirtualBox 3.1.4 | Keywords: | |
| Cc: | Guest type: | Windows | |
| Host type: | other |
Description
Celestia, Open-Source OpenGL application renders textures incorrectly with VBox 3.1.0 additions. It worked fine with 3.0.10.
Host: Windows Vista 32-bit, Core 2 P8600, NVIDIA GeForce 9700M GTS, VBox 3.1.0
Guest: Windows XP
It looks like a regression in OpenGL component.
-Technologov, 9.12.2009.
Attachments
-
Windows XP-2010-01-25-19-19-49.log
(41.2 KB) -
added by Technologov 8 years ago.
- XP-on-XP VBox Log, Intel GPU
-
Celestia-Earth.PNG
(291.9 KB) -
added by Technologov 8 years ago.
- Celestia-Earth.PNG -- correct rendering
-
Celestia-Earth-broken.PNG
(114.4 KB) -
added by Technologov 8 years ago.
- Celestia-Earth-broken.PNG -- incorrect rendering, VBox 3.1.0
-
XP-on-Vista-NVIDIA.log
(65.9 KB) -
added by Technologov 8 years ago.
- XP-on-Vista VBOX log NVIDIA GPU, VBox 3.1.2
-
Celestia-Earth-broken2.png
(63.7 KB) -
added by Technologov 8 years ago.
- Celestia-Earth-broken2.png screenshot on NVIDIA
-
Windows XP 3D-2010-01-29-12-43-41.log
(41.3 KB) -
added by Technologov 8 years ago.
- XP-on-XP VBox Log, ATI GPU, VBox 3.1.4-BETA1
Change History
comment:3 Changed 8 years ago by leonid
I've checked it on winxp/winxp combo with latest vbox and it looks correct. Could you post a screenshot of corrupted textures please and steps to reproduce...as this app features alot of objects...and manually checking em one by one will take a while :)
Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
-
attachment
Windows XP-2010-01-25-19-19-49.log
added
XP-on-XP VBox Log, Intel GPU
Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
-
attachment
Celestia-Earth.PNG
added
Celestia-Earth.PNG -- correct rendering
Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
-
attachment
Celestia-Earth-broken.PNG
added
Celestia-Earth-broken.PNG -- incorrect rendering, VBox 3.1.0
comment:4 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
Correct rendering can be observed on host, or in guests in 3.0.10.
Incorrect rendering can be observed in VBox 3.1.0/3.1.2 guests, with Intel/ATI/NVIDIA GPUs.
-Technologov
comment:5 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
Steps to reproduce: "Start Celestia", and wait 5 seconds so it moves to "Earth".
comment:6 Changed 8 years ago by leonid
Hm, it works ok here still. Although on ATI/NVidia GPUs. It seems to be an issue with older cards, like intel with opengl 1.4 you have.
comment:7 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
I have this problem on NVIDIA and ATI GPUs too... on both XP and Vista 32bit Hosts.
Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
-
attachment
XP-on-Vista-NVIDIA.log
added
XP-on-Vista VBOX log NVIDIA GPU, VBox 3.1.2
Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
-
attachment
Celestia-Earth-broken2.png
added
Celestia-Earth-broken2.png screenshot on NVIDIA
comment:8 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
I have attached logs and screenshot to show how it looks like on NVIDIA.
comment:9 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
3.1.4 BETA1 looks the same as "Celestia-Earth-broken.PNG" on ATI GPU.
Host: Windows XP, Core 2, ATI Radehon HD 3850, VBox 3.1.4-BETA1.
Guest: Windows XP, VBox 3.1.4-BETA1 GA installed.
-Technologov
Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
-
attachment
Windows XP 3D-2010-01-29-12-43-41.log
added
XP-on-XP VBox Log, ATI GPU, VBox 3.1.4-BETA1
comment:10 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
Problem still exists with VBox 3.1.4 (final, r57640). I have reinstalled GA.
Host: Windows Vista 32-bit, Core 2 P8600, NVIDIA GeForce 9700M GTS, VBox 3.1.4
-Technologov
comment:12 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
This problem is still true as of VBox 3.2.0-BETA1.
comment:13 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
Problem exists in VBox 3.2.0; This is a regression vs 3.0.10.
-Technologov
comment:14 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
v3.2.8. Fixed, Verified.
-Technologov
comment:15 Changed 8 years ago by Technologov
FIXED in 3.2.8
comment:16 Changed 8 years ago by frank
- Status changed from new to closed
- Resolution set to fixed
Thanks for the feedback!
This bug looks related to bug #5720
-Technologov