[vbox-dev] Capturing a device usbLibDevCfgDrGet DeviceIoControl 1 fail winEr (31)
Ribhi Kamal
rbhkamal at gmail.com
Tue Oct 18 16:36:59 GMT 2011
Thanks Mikhail,
Please let me know if you need me to test any patches or if you have any
questions. I can consistently reproduce the bug
I'd just like to point out a few more things:
- When using USB filters (vs controlvm usbattach), the Smart-card reader
device always gets captured correctly **if** it is removed from the host and
plugged back in. Or if it is inserted *after* a VM is started.
- Getting the device description fails even when there are no virtual
machines running and no devices are captured. But only works after the
device is captured (See my last email)
Thanks,
Ribhi
On Tue, Oct 18, 2011 at 9:02 AM, Mikhail Sennikovsky <
mikhail.sennikovsky at oracle.com> wrote:
> **
> Hi Rabhi,
>
> The usbLibDevCfgDrGet can now really fail when querying device info on
> device capture. This is because the device being captured gets (soft-)
> re-plugged, so it really disappears and then appears back, and doing
> IOCTL_USB_GET_DESCRIPTOR_FROM_NODE_CONNECTION and thing like this could fail
> within this time slot.
> The problem is that since description of one and the same device could
> differ (depending on whether usbLibDevCfgDrGet fails or not), VBoxSVC may
> think it is two different devices. There is a logic in VBoxSVC that should
> prevent things like this, unfortunately it is hard to make it work 100%
> correct.
> I'll have another look into it t see if it can be improved to work properly
> once I have a spare minute.
>
> Thanks,
> Mikhail
>
>
> On 10/14/2011 7:18 PM, Ribhi Kamal wrote:
>
> For the issue in vboxsvc, it seems like its a locking issue. See attached
> log for more info.
>
> Thanks,
> Ribhi
> On Thu, Oct 13, 2011 at 2:02 PM, Ribhi Kamal <rbhkamal at gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> Alright, this is a very old problem that used to happens A LOT with the
>> very first version of vbox that had usb support. The problem went a way for
>> a while and now its back. It also happens in both my compiled and
>> Oracle binaries.
>>
>> Here is what happens:
>> The smart-card reader is inserted to the host and a virtual machine is
>> running (nothing is captured yet)
>>
>> vboxmanage list usbhost, shows the smartcard device but without the
>> Manufacturer and product strings.
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>VBoxManage.exe list usbhost
>> Host USB Devices:
>> UUID: 7344ae78-9c6a-429f-a5d7-95838e6084e7
>>
>> VendorId: 0x04e6 (04E6)
>> ProductId: 0x511c (511C)
>> Revision: 5.24 (0524)
>> Address: {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0002
>> Current State: Busy
>>
>> Next, when trying to attach the device:
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>VBoxManage.exe controlvm testing usbattach
>> {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0002
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>VBoxManage.exe list usbhost
>> Host USB Devices:
>> UUID: 7344ae78-9c6a-429f-a5d7-95838e6084e7
>>
>> VendorId: 0x04e6 (04E6)
>> ProductId: 0x511c (511C)
>> Revision: 5.24 (0524)
>> Address: {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0002
>> Current State: Captured
>>
>> UUID: c78f6adb-5884-4bd2-8449-a06a892f0629
>>
>> VendorId: 0x04e6 (04E6)
>> ProductId: 0x511c (511C)
>> Revision: 5.24 (0524)
>> Manufacturer: Axalto
>> Product: Reflex USB v3
>> Address:
>> \\?\usb#vid_80ee&pid_cafe#21120614404073#{00873fdf-cafe-80ee-aa5e-00c04fb1720b
>> }
>> Current State: Held
>>
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>VBoxManage.exe list usbhost
>> Host USB Devices:
>> UUID: 7344ae78-9c6a-429f-a5d7-95838e6084e7
>>
>> VendorId: 0x04e6 (04E6)
>> ProductId: 0x511c (511C)
>> Revision: 5.24 (0524)
>> Address: {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0002
>> Current State: Captured
>>
>> UUID: c78f6adb-5884-4bd2-8449-a06a892f0629
>>
>> VendorId: 0x04e6 (04E6)
>> ProductId: 0x511c (511C)
>> Revision: 5.24 (0524)
>> Manufacturer: Axalto
>> Product: Reflex USB v3
>> Address: {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0002
>> Current State: Busy
>> Now the description for the smartcard reader is visable and the capture
>> will work.
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>VBoxManage.exe controlvm testing
>> usbattach {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0002
>> VBoxManage.exe: error: USB device '<unknown>' with UUID
>> {7344ae78-9c6a-429f-a5d7-95838e6084e7} is busy with a previous request.
>> Please try again later
>> VBoxManage.exe: error: Details: code E_INVALIDARG (0x80070057), component
>> HostUSBDevice, interface IHostUSBDevice, callee IUnknown
>> VBoxManage.exe: error: Context: "AttachUSBDevice(usbId.raw())" at line 832
>> of file VBoxManageControlVM.cpp
>>
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>VBoxManage.exe controlvm testing usbattach
>> *c78f6adb-5884-4bd2-8449-a06a892f0629*
>>
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>VBoxManage.exe list usbhost
>> Host USB Devices:
>> UUID: 7344ae78-9c6a-429f-a5d7-95838e6084e7
>>
>> VendorId: 0x04e6 (04E6)
>> ProductId: 0x511c (511C)
>> Revision: 5.24 (0524)
>> Address: {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0002
>> Current State: Captured
>>
>> UUID: c78f6adb-5884-4bd2-8449-a06a892f0629
>>
>> VendorId: 0x04e6 (04E6)
>> ProductId: 0x511c (511C)
>> Revision: 5.24 (0524)
>> Manufacturer: Axalto
>> Product: Reflex USB v3
>> Address:
>> \\?\usb#vid_80ee&pid_cafe#21120614404073#{00873fdf-cafe-80ee-aa5e-00c04fb1720b
>> }
>> Current State: Captured
>>
>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>
>>
>> I'm not sure, but I think this problem was not in 4.1.2 and definitely not
>> in 4.0.12.
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Ribhi
>> On Thu, Oct 13, 2011 at 12:12 PM, Ribhi Kamal <rbhkamal at gmail.com>wrote:
>>
>>> More than often I see the following error when trying to capture the
>>> axalto smartcard reader:
>>> VBoxSVC.log
>>> VirtualBox (XP)COM Server 4.1.51_OSE r38834 win.amd64 (Oct 11 2011
>>> 12:53:24) release log
>>> 00:00:00.000 main Log opened 2011-10-13T15:58:02.008196600Z
>>> 00:00:00.000 main OS Product: Windows 7
>>> 00:00:00.000 main OS Release: 6.1.7601
>>> 00:00:00.000 main Executable:
>>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new\VBOXSVC.exe
>>> 00:00:00.000 main Process ID: 2152
>>> 00:00:00.000 main Package type: WINDOWS_64BITS_GENERIC (OSE)
>>> 00:00:00.016 Loading settings file
>>> "C:\Users\tester/.VirtualBox\VirtualBox.xml" with version "1.12-windows"
>>> 00:00:00.156 usbLibDevCfgDrGet: DeviceIoControl 1 fail winEr
>>> (31)
>>> 00:00:00.453 VDInit finished
>>> 00:00:00.453 Loading settings file "C:\Users\tester\VirtualBox
>>> VMs\testing\testing.vbox" with version "1.11-windows"
>>> 00:00:01.794 USBPROXY usbLibDevCfgDrGet: DeviceIoControl 1 fail winEr
>>> (31)
>>> ------------------------------------------------------------
>>>
>>> After the capture the device will be left in the following state:
>>> C:\Users\tester\Desktop\bin-new>VBoxManage.exe list usbhost
>>> Host USB Devices:
>>> UUID: 717a5a0d-3510-4b9e-a5f5-2830de45ff3f
>>> VendorId: 0x04b9 (04B9)
>>> ProductId: 0x1000 (1000)
>>> Revision: 1.0 (0100)
>>> Manufacturer: Rainbow Technologies
>>> Product: iKey 1000
>>> Address:
>>> \\?\usb#vid_80ee&pid_cafe#5&35ea7c2c&0&1#{00873fdf-cafe-80ee-aa5e-00c04fb1720b
>>> }
>>> Current State: Captured
>>>
>>> UUID: 407b053e-0566-47de-b293-a81781524dbf
>>> VendorId: 0x04e6 (04E6)
>>> ProductId: 0x511c (511C)
>>> Revision: 5.24 (0524)
>>> Address: {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0002
>>> *Current State: Captured*
>>>
>>> UUID: d027769c-8edb-4e12-a93e-56ff4e0614c6
>>> VendorId: 0x0b97 (0B97)
>>> ProductId: 0x7772 (7772)
>>> Revision: 1.16 (0116)
>>> Manufacturer: O2
>>> Product: O2Micro CCID SC Reader
>>> Address: {50dd5230-ba8a-11d1-bf5d-0000f805f530}\0001
>>> Current State: Busy
>>>
>>>
>>> There are two problems:
>>> 1- The capture issue. (maybe retry usbLibDevCfgDrGet?)
>>> 2- Handling the error is not done properly in vboxsvc(?) and the device
>>> is left the "Captured" state eventhough it is not.
>>>
>>>
>>> Please let me know how I can help.
>>>
>>> Thanks,
>>> -- Ribhi
>>>
>>
>>
>>
>> --
>> -- Ribhi
>>
>
>
>
> --
> -- Ribhi
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> vbox-dev mailing listvbox-dev at virtualbox.orghttps://www.virtualbox.org/mailman/listinfo/vbox-dev
>
>
>
--
-- Ribhi
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www.virtualbox.org/pipermail/vbox-dev/attachments/20111018/9398c0bf/attachment.html>
More information about the vbox-dev
mailing list